Ranjit B Rai……..
“In North Nescafe is popular. In South its Filter Coffee…..PM Modi speaks chaste Hindi in the North, and excellent English in the South at Defexpo………Viva Le Difference ! PM knows how to re-boot.
10TH Defexpo 2018 was the show that saw Indian Private Defence Industry and PSUs tie up with many foreign partners with least bureaucratic interference or permissions, hoping for orders and production so exports can take place. “Only when your Services use Indian wares can you export”, Thales lady rep at show spoke at FICCI seminar. RM Mrs Nirmala Sitharaman wants exports at any cost from corridors in UP and Tamil Nadu, both political corridors but said I cannot force services to buy India made.
From 1970s the Navy had foreign tie ups when it made Leanders at MDSL. Most equipment flowed from Yarrow and Soviet partnerships including nuclear submarines. All new builds, are extensions on that design, and 72 warships “Made in India” in the same eco-system that Army and Air Force operated, but they are now set to follow and Defexpo showed that.
CNS Admiral Sunil Lanba alluded to this in his Key Note Navy speech arranged by FICCI with RM and COAS though he is Chairman COSC. COAS did not speak after. KPMG released a noting Defence depicting how PSUs get away with no interest on loans, give no performance guarantees and take massive time and money escalations.
This post includes a generic IDF analysis after traveling South to Kerala & Maharashtra. Defexpo 2018 was forty five kilometers from Chennai in hot-humid weather in traffic jams. No shuttle buses were thought of. In parts of India and at the exhibition IDF saw more money in hands of those there. Planes fly full and those who came to DEFEXPO had individual service Chalets for size.
IDF basked in advances of military technology in 7 air conditioned make shift halls done up by Enpro (which was on a marsh a month ago cleared by a Defence PSU ). The outdoor display held Tanks, Radars and Guns and vehicles.
IDF attended four conferences with same themes in lovely halls and mixed with top brass, met foreign defence manufacturers, PSUs/ Indian defence companies, and few foreign delegations and Russians who are warm when you speak Russians. France, Israel, UK, South Korea , Russia, USA and Europe had pavilions. A heartening feature was Navy’s retiring technical Admirals are now in Naval Group, or CSL or Brahmos or MDL or L&T etc so it was like meeting ‘comrades in arms’ with frank talk.
Indian Attaches from abroad were flitting from VIP lounges to Indian stalls collecting brochures on what was a photo op and jolly for them in Delhi on 9th Apr, and then at Defexpo. They were given a booklet for exports by MOD and DRDO.
IDF only saw few mid level service officers from HQs. CAS came only on PM day. IAF staff could have also gained from viewing the advancements and IL-76s & C-130s could have brought them in hordes as IAF did for selected media. Money being spent seemed no problem as MOD charged exhibitors heavily. The cost of the temporary structures on a marsh etc vs a Exhibition building needs audit for the future.
Young start up made presentations before COAS and Industry. Half of India’s educated youth is on the move as never before and with money that can be borrowed and aspirations but what daunts is the chaotic ways that Indians enjoy. Its like Amrit rising like a Lotus from the dirty waters, a Hindu’s belief. L&T’s Mr J Patil gave them hope.
Indians can innovate for defence and need support. PM Modi promised a better eco-system for them. Hope PMO is listening to make easier funds available to SMSEs like it was made to set up Defexpo 2018 ! IDF feels NPAs may make loans difficult, and FM wants to have a say in defence defence budget is lowest at 1.5 % of GDP heard mentioned at the show !
IDF is convinced that whether the government or Parliament work, Stock market seems unaffected in spite of NPAs poor internal security and law and order as Police is dominated by the politicians, and even a non secular right wing Government with Hindutva whatever Hindutva is. This has confused the non BJP nation to restlessness. So elections will be on caste, jati and religion more than ever before and Defence Services cannot escape. Defexpo re-enforced this view by talk with many at the show.
India has a lot to offer in its defence sector but its just like the parking arrangements at Defexpo. It was difficult to find your vehicle and get out on the single lane village road as trucks were coming the other way. Indians personal interest works against India’s national interests which politicians call unity in diversity. It has been PSUs and bureaucratic interest versus private business as retd VCOAS Lt Gen Saha of Society of Defence Manufacturers said in the presence of COAS Gen Bipin Rawat , “ India’s private vehicle industry has become world class but Army’s vehicles are still to”. COAS has taken steps to alter this but it is big Army with varied climatic conditions and terrain and needs, he explained but wowed to fight the next war with Indian weapons.
IDF lists some of the big tie ups that were signed or announced in anticipation of exports or orders
- PSU HAL and private MAHINDRAs will make F-18s.
- Goa Shipyard Ltd GSL signed with MTU owned by Rolls Royce for large more modern new OPV engines, and Griffon for Hovercraft and to make a simulator for Scorpenes. GRSE also had tie ups.
- L&T tied with MBDA, after Thales as news spread that DRDO had tested its QR SAM while orders for Spike and Javelin are pending.
- ALPHA Technologies already has Israeli tie ups and its IRNSS-8 made satellite was successfully launched by ISRO’s PSLV on 12th The quiet tie up company like Data Patterns and another Astra.
- Russian OEMs signed with Indian companies, and Kalyani and Adani new entrants with Turkish and other offerings. Reliance did not have a stall like other shipyards.
- Coast Guard with DG Rajendras Singh was very active after holding the commissioning of AOPV by RRM Dr Subash Bhamre built ahead of time by L&T.
- DRDO showed all its products as did HAL and BEL.
The top leaders of Industry seen at show and conferences were Rosboronexport’s supporters Vladimir N Drozhzhov and Igor Sevanstianov for pending Rostec’s 226 helicopters, Mr Hota of BEML launching a 4X4 with capacity for 12, Dr Sudhir Misra at Brahmos with news the air launched version will launch by year end, Mr J Patil of L&T was at three conferences, Mr Christpher Nurit of Lockheed for F- 16s calling them ‘Gap Fillers’, Naval Group’s head in Mumbai and Mr Pierre Buausset Airbus’s MD in India, Mr Pratyush pushing Boeing and UK’s Mr Guto Bebb, BEL’s Mr MV Gowtama and visitors from Korea and delegations, Mr Sartaj Singh of Solar who supports ORF .
IDF can confirm half of India the uneducated rural and agricultural India live in poverty especially in political BJP powerful North India as getting votes is their industry. . Not much has changed except mobiles and TV, ever since Independence by Congress or by this powerfully led BJP RSS Hindutva government in the last four years which neglected Internal security. Poor and non Hindus and women have suffered and police has lost policing and how CBI does hundreds of cases justice is beyond IDF.
No wonder PM Modi was greeted with ‘Go Back Modi’ and even no Modiji on visit to DEFEXPO and he avoided public, using helipads. The challenge was over water disputes but there is anger in South India and by accident through two rapes by BJP in UP and Kashmir whose shadow was felt at Defexpo in chats. Politics with elections now includes personal lives and people worry PM’s personal marital status could become a political issue, as elections near and more and more women are challenging BJP’s tactics to protect their leaders over rapes etc.
India is ranked 133rd in the World’s Happiness Index but the survey does not know Indians happiness lies in its chaos and confusion, religious beliefs, many gods Ramayana and Mahibharat and the Gita and politics and Indian have huge tolerance levels. India’s military is strong in the same manner.