Ranjit B Rai

This is a letter from America after President Trump has done a deal with Kim Jong Un. It  was the talk at the FDR Library and was asked why India and Pakistan cannot do such a peace deal.

IDF was stumped and answered that its not easy and it is connected with Pakistan’s Army  with China nowAfghansistan. Eyebrows were raised so IDF had to explain.

 Leaders with strategy can do wonders,  even if peace  be for the short term,  but wonders happen only after a strategy is devised and followed to the hilt. Businesses live by strategy. India is still groping  for a strategy to deal with Pakistan as many and even Rand predict Pakistan  will fail by 2025, the way it is going.  India feels it can  wear Pakistan  down. Time means little in India.

This is also wishful thinking and IDF has to meet  one who can predict more that 5 years and  China is an elephant in Pakistan’s room, that India has done a peace deal with on the borders. This gives respite to CPEC on the border is the Chinese view.

But who could predict how much  has changed  in US  North Korea relations  in months. Or what President FDR did in the 1930s when USA and the world were  in deep economic depression. FDR gave a new deal and helped farmers and sent poor to work and  toplant millions of trees to make USA richand to industrialize in four years. In  1991   FM Dr. Manmohan Singh did open economy to stave off a failed economy. India did not follow through with a strategy for famers or industry to open to FDI but just hoped for ‘Ache Dins’ for shining India that BJP Money Bags late Minister PromodMahajan coined.  Not much has changed. Poverty is at 30% and young have no jobs or social security, that FDR gave poor. Communal strife seems more.

But   President Trump has shown and executed  a wonder  with North Korea to make it move  towards de-nuclearisation.

So   IDF asks,  has Prime Minister Modi  failed with Pakistan for short term peace on the border or  in Afghanistan where   India has opposed TALIBAN tooth and nail hoping to revive   the defunct Northern Alliance (NA) it had as a friend  in the 1980s with Russia. China and  Russia have now   boarded the Taliban bus which USA wanted to join ???  USA leans on India a lot and has stopped aid to Pakistan and Pakistan continues and on to its elections next month. PM Modi did not meet Pakistan President at SCO meet in BEIJING.

PM Modi had invited Pakistan leadership to India and visited leadership there, but India  has failed to understand and talk to the Deep State Army in Pakistan which controls policy for India and Afghanistan.  IDF doubts India’s leadership  has  attempted  a viable strategy, or  offered a branch to the people of Kashmir but  left it to the Army and its Infantry Chief Gen BipinRawatto fight all the political fires on the border  and in the Valley, and  LOC and what Pakistan calls working boundary in J&K near Jammu on the International boundary, that BSF guards.

PM Modi has globe trotted and hugged many leaders and made friends far away to raise India’s stature,  but India’s neighbourhood seems peeved with India as PM talks down to people and mentions names of past leaders in  derogatory terms as if they did nothing, not behooving a true leader. Biographies of great Leaders tell this. 

On the other hand President Donald Trump has just departed  Singapore immediately after holding talks with North Korean leader Kim Jong Un and signed  an upending of relations in  a ‘comprehensive document’. It sounded like the 1972 SimlaAgreement  which saw peace in India with give and takes,  and hopes,  but India never followed up over Kashmir and its has now complicated itself to implement  Art 370 or abrogate it ! IDF asks did India lack a strategy ?May be BJP-RSS will come with two third majority in 2019 or earlier and change the Constitution. It could be a strategy but there is gamble in that.

Trump has expressed his willingness to invite Kim to the White House, after the latter committed to ‘complete denuclearisation of the Korean Peninsula’ in the joint document signed  on 12 the June, which  Secretary of State USA Pompeo  like India’s  NSA  negotiated and media said China will not allow and may even   de-rail it.


In Afghanistan after killing 70, the Taliban were able  dictate a welcomed  Three Day Cease Fire for Ramzan’s  Id. This   shows Taliban has gained  more power with successful attacks on Government forces including the Afghan Army and Police and US Forces and the public. The Taliban has also targeted the Indian Embassy with minor successes.  India   hates the Taliban and Pakistan which hates India almost  like Kim Jong Un hated Trump but both have struck a deal for temporary gains. China is also agreeing to import $ 50 bill more from USA, another trade strategy of Trump. But China is bidding for time. India could also do with a quiet cease fired border, which only the Deep State in Pakistan can agree to.

One  learns strategy as the main tool in the Navy which is a strategic force so it  cannot help in Kashmir like Army does, but keeps China guessing in the Maritime field.

“Vive La Difference” as the French would say.

Pakistan is run by its Army and the ISI that support the Taliban which  is largely founded  on the strength of its Jehadi terrorist policy as the “Home of Terror” and have used the courage of Jehadi volunteers to keep the entire Indian Army and political set up busy, to the detriment of attending to the true rise of India. Now Pakistan has a close ally in China to fund and  needle India which is stronger in the only field than China called the Geographic Seas by  the  Indian Navy’s  attributes. But for how long is Indian Navy going to be the factor  to keep China thinking is the question unless the Navy is funded and expanded and nourished.

The story of how Pakistan’s leadership led by Generals like Pervez Kayani and Musharraf learnt how to sort out the  powerful Soviet Army and throw them out of Afghanistan has been explained by  PrasunSengupta in Trident Blogspot . He lists and  shows how funds came from USA, Saudi Arabia and PM Mahathir in Malaysia and  the same bitter pill of terror has been  hurting USA, India and the whole world. The Pakistani Army has  used drug money as ammunition to keep Taliban attacking President Ghani’s weak Army, foreign troops, Indians and the Administration and controls half of Afghanistan.

But a solution can be attempted through Pakistan either with   war or with talks. Today’s wars do not gain much as USA’s wars in Iraq, Libya and Syria have shown.


However every insurgent agency including Taliban looks for political power and Pakistan  leans on  war lords and Poppy trade in millions of dollars  in Afghanistan for  terror attacks to show their muscle to  the world and society. Afghanistan and the world looks to India for help and most nations  except India have talked to Taliban. This  distrust of one another is a de-stabilising factor.


In the 1980s  the Northern Alliance (NA)  propped up by Russia and Indian Intelligence and Army with  arms  made sure North of Afghanistan did not fall to Taliban and Pakistan. Does India still live on hopes of NA which is non-existent as Russia is now leaning on Pakistan. The Indian Army has little say now except to train the Afghan Army whose morale and wages are on the decline. If   GOOD TALIBAN is the answer in Afghanistan it cannot be achieved without a definitive India Pakistan strategy and one of no talks till terror abates  is like which came first the Chicken or the egg. The challenge to chalk a strategy is enormous. Shan Na Varuna.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *